Flint Ross All articles
Business Development

Second Time Around: Five Tests Before a Proposal Is Reissued

Flint Ross
Second Time Around: Five Tests Before a Proposal Is Reissued

Photo: printed business proposal document with pen and laptop on a desk in a professional office, via image.slidesharecdn.com

Every firm has a proposal library, and every firm should. Rebuilding a scope, a fee schedule and a set of terms from nothing is a waste of senior time, and the quality of a document drafted under pressure is rarely better than the quality of one drafted well and adapted carefully.

The trouble is that adaptation is the step that gets skipped. A proposal carries an argument, and the argument was built for a particular business at a particular moment. Reissue it unchanged and you have not saved time; you have lent a new client someone else's thinking. Below are five questions worth twenty minutes before the document leaves the building.

1. Whose problem is this document solving?

Read the opening two pages as though you were the new client. The symptoms described, the growth trajectory, the structure of the finance function, the regulatory exposures — do they belong to this business or to the last one?

Scope drift is subtler than a copy-and-paste error. A proposal written for a company preparing for sale tends to assume a horizon of eighteen months and a bias towards presenting the business well. Send it to a family business thinking about the next generation and the shape of the work is wrong before a single fee line is read. Check the deliverables against what the client actually said in the first meeting, not against what the template says a project of this name contains.

2. Does the price still hold?

Fees age quickly and unevenly. Day rates move at the annual review; subcontractor and specialist costs move faster. Check three things: that the rates quoted are current, that the VAT treatment is right for this client's circumstances, and that the resourcing assumptions still reflect who would do the work.

Then interrogate the engagement status. An associate quoted as delivering the work may have been promoted twice since the proposal was written, and a fee built on their old rate is a margin problem waiting to be discovered in month three. Where the firm engages contractors, the off-payroll working rules need a fresh status determination for each engagement rather than an inherited one.

3. Has the risk moved since this was written?

The limitation of liability clause, the indemnity, the insurance position and the data processing terms were drafted against a previous scope. If the scope has grown, the cap may no longer be proportionate to the exposure. If the client will now hand over personal data, the processing schedule needs to exist and be accurate.

Two clauses that were optional three years ago are now standard. The first governs the firm's use of AI tools in delivery: what may be put through a third-party model, what may not, and who is accountable for the output. The second covers subcontracting and supplier due diligence, where clients increasingly ask for confirmation that modern slavery and security standards extend down the chain. A proposal silent on both invites a question the firm would rather answer in writing than across a table.

4. Whose evidence is in here?

Case studies, benchmarks and testimonials travel badly. A named client in a proposal to a competitor is a confidentiality breach with a delay fuse. An anonymised case study that is obviously identifiable is worse.

Check that every example is either consented to for this use or genuinely unidentifiable, and that any figure described as typical is still typical. A benchmark drawn from a 2022 dataset presented without a date is a claim the firm cannot defend if challenged. If the evidence feels thin once the recycled material is removed, that is useful information about the proposal, not a reason to keep it.

5. Which paragraph are you going to rewrite?

The opening. Always the opening.

The first hundred words of a proposal tell the client whether the firm has understood the problem. They cannot be inherited, because the problem is not the same problem. Rewrite them from the notes of the conversation that actually took place: the client's words, the specific constraint they described, the decision they are trying to make. It is a twenty-minute task and it does more for the document than any other edit.

While you are there, rewrite the closing paragraph too. It should say what happens next, who will call whom, and by when. Recycled proposals frequently end with a recycled ending, which is to say a sentence that commits nobody.

A note on the file itself

Before reissue, rename the document, reset the version number, and record who adapted it and against which client brief. Firms that track this discover something uncomfortable and useful: the same proposal is often recycled three or four times, and the quality degrades with each pass while the confidence behind it does not.

Recycling is not the problem. Recycling without re-reading is. Five questions, honestly answered, will tell you whether you are saving time or simply deferring the work to a point where the client is in the room and the fee is already agreed.

All Articles

Related Articles

After the Report Is Filed: A Ninety-Day Test of Whether Advice Travelled

After the Report Is Filed: A Ninety-Day Test of Whether Advice Travelled

The Silent Attendee: Terms of Engagement for Automated Minute-Taking

The Silent Attendee: Terms of Engagement for Automated Minute-Taking

The Internal Client: Holding Your Own Firm to the Standard You Sell

The Internal Client: Holding Your Own Firm to the Standard You Sell